This city, as a city, makes no sense at all. Perhaps (probably) once upon a time it did make sense, but now it really does serve purely (excuse the cliche, and all thosethat no doubt will follow) as some kind of grown-up Disneyland. I.e. it is a fun park.
I suppose most cities have some kind of picturesque area which can exist only in equilibrium with the more ugly, more utilitarian, areas around it. But Venice is like a whole city of this. (Mestre, Marghera, etc, being the essential, extremely ugly, peripheral areas.)
The best thing about Mestre was the mosaic on the side of a building we passed on our way to a police station. |
Of course Venice itself is not all magical and beautiful either (although it is a lot of both of those things). It is also very smelly, and not, it seems for now at least, from the canals. The dogs of Venice have a lot to answer for. Which really means the ageing (aged) population of Venice has a lot to answer for. That at least is one area where the blame can't be transferred to the tourists. (Well, some of the local tourists maybe, but not really the foreigners.)
Can't they employ some street cleaners?! Or at least increase (or create) penalties for leaving dog shit on the street? Maybe it's too hard to chase down offenders through the maze of alleyways, but then surely most of the offenders are elderly women and their horrible little snappy creatures*... So, back to the first idea of hiring a team of street cleaners. Surely the pong of ammonia is not included in the preservation of the 'elegant decay'.
* The other morning on our way to the giardini we passed the chaotic scene of a recent dog attack in the lane alongside the fruttivendolo (under that saint). One elderly woman was sitting in the ground clutching her leg, which looked like the calf had been completely ripped open, a fresh red comic book blood splatter on the road beside her. Then around the corner another old biddy was clutching her grinning (if dogs can grin), fluffy little pooch protectively. No medics had arrived yet, although we were pretty close to the osepdale, but there were a lot of people around to fuss over both parties, everyone having exited their shops to partake in the commotion.
Of course I'm a sucker for the elegant decay. I'm certainly not one for getting all Futurist on Venice.** Like some people pop bubble wrap, there's nothing like peeling giant strips of paint off walls (or in Venice's case, crumbling a bit of plaster) to satisfy an urge (and drive F mad).
** (The Futurist manifesto Against Traditionalist Venice is worth a read.)
- - - - - - - -
My impression so far is that it is the cruise ships that make the Venetian world turn. There is a constant flotilla of cruise ships into the lagoon. Everyday on our commute between the farm and work we would see the line of cruise ships waiting to be guided through the city, sometimes 9 or 10 gigantic ships just waiting there. These ships bring hundreds of thousands of visitors into Venice, every day, which in terms of the infrastructure here, including the narrow ally system, really doesn't make sense. (Of course they are their own floating hotels and restaurants.)
They range in size from little adriatic explorers to massive high rise tankers. Yesterday afternoon there was a most deep and incredible rumbling through the pavilion when one of the biggies was passing by the giardini. Such massive vibrations and water displacement - it's no wonder this place is sinking.
My favourite cruise ship, the Michelangelo. So long but only one story high, it looks like it has lost it's top 6 levels. |
Finn found out somewhere along the way that the lagoon here is naturally only about 8ft deep at its deepest, but that they dredge channels in it up to 50 (or 100?) feet deep in order to get the cruise liners in. That means there's a hell of a lot more water moving around.
Two large-ish liners being guided through the Giudecca canal. |
I wonder how much of the capital raised through letting them all in (from the entry/docking fees they have to pay) goes into repairing the foundations of Venice. And then there are all the tourists, spending their days shopping for souvenirs, ensuring that the city is overrun with masks and glass trinkets.
A tug guiding the backside of a cruise ship past Zattere. |
Must be a good view from up there, especially from the ball court. (Our view was from the second or third story apartment window where Jim & Ness stayed.) |
Coming straight for us on Rio tera Giuseppe Garibaldi. |
Perhaps it was high tide, but the other evening when we were sitting in the piazza enjoying a spritz on the way home, Finn became completely distracted by the manoeuvrings of a gondolier passing down the canal across from us. He was trickily angling the boat right onto its side (without tipping out either of the passengers) in order to fit under the narrow archway of a bridge. Impressive stuff, although possibly a less romantic and more startling part of the ride for the couple onboard.
|
Finn sitting on the footpath holding his feet above the water line - the water which is covering the old footpath level . |
And a measuring stick across the canal for when the water level gets really high. |
- - - - - - -
So, smelly and sinking, what else...
Hopefully in my other posts I have conveyed how much fun we're having, so I won't go over that too much again now, even if this is feeling a bit down on the place. Really I am not down on the place at all, it is just all so different and quite strange, it does make an impression.
I am quite a convert to the non-existance of cars. I mean, of course while we're living in Venice we have no need for a car, so what I mean is - I really love living in a pedestrian city. Yes, the canals are like roads and the boats and barges are like cars and trucks, but it's also very different. For one, the bridges ensure that walking is continuous here - no stopping and waiting for traffic. Unless something went terribly wrong, there's no way a boat could knock down a pedestrian. And no bikes either of course, although I wouldn't say it's entirely uninterrupted. Venice is all about walking in zig zags. Zig zagging through the myriad of alleyways and bridges, and, within the alleyways and bridges, zig zagging around the masses of slow slow slow tourists (especially around mask shop windows and on picturesque bridges), and slow slow slow old women with their shopping trolleys and ankle biting dogs. Not to mention all the pushchairs in this place. What happened to the practical backpack?! There are endless bridges here - that's what Venice is about - which means endless steps, it's quite simple. Anyway, one gets used to it, and one also learns alternative (especially to Rialto and San Marco) routes. Getting from our place to the giardini is a dream, we are peripheral enough not to be too too tourist busy, and around the Arsenale (where it does get busier) it's all nice and wide and easy.
A gang of trolley-wielding women. |
We succeeded in overtaking them as they rounded the Arsenale. |
But, back to the boats. Mostly there is surprisingly little variation in the boats here (I'm talking about local boats now, not cruise liners or visiting super yachts). Yes, they have boats for every purpose, but I don't feel like I can say there are boats of all shapes and sizes, there is a lot of uniformity. There are gondolas (for tourists to take canal tours in), rowed by one man standing at the back. Water taxis driven by one guy at the front with a cab in the back for the passengers. Barges that carry everything being delivered into the city, and barges that take everything else out of the city. Ambulances, police, the fire brigade, and hearses are all the same kind of boat, kitted out with their own special features (see Recovery for the coffin manoeuvring apparatus). Vaporetto are the water buses and they come in two sizes. And then there are the private boats, and they are almost all exactly the same - open top wooden or fibreglass dinghies with outboard motors (the boy racers have neon lights, giant sound systems, and, if not flames, some kind of speedy design along the sides). The most startling observation we've made about the boats really though is that they are only driven by men. In the more than three months we've been here I have seen only one female vaporetto driver and one girl racer. That's it. No housewife popping around in the boat to get her shopping done, she takes her trolley and walks. Women, it seems, do not drive the boats in Venice, it is a very gender specific role, instead they lie around sunning themselves in bikinis on the bow (well, some of them). (Sorry I haven't taken any photos of this kind of spectacle. I guess I should've done a boat series while it was still hot hot summer.)
I think impressions of this place will be quite different come November, come the rain and the fog and the cold. So far we have only been here for summer, for the busiest tourist period. I'm not sure that there is every really an off-season now, I think tourism is fairly continuous the year round (I have heard that in February it's almost deserted, but we'll be gone too by then). It's not just that I want to see Venice without tourists though - in some ways that would be terribly depressing I think. It's just there are really so so so so many tourists that they cause their own kind of distracting slow-moving hyped-up spectacle, and experiencing a calmer, quieter Venice could be nice. I guess I will let you know.
29 September 2011